Jun 29, 2011 clapp 2001 explained that recognizing the risks involved in the integration of multiple products into a cots based system is an important task that required actions within any software project. Though it is mostly popularized by the linux operating system, it is not limited to it. Third international conference, iccbss 2004, redondo beach, ca, usa. Implementing a cots system design using raytheon ipds. This process is evaluated to identify essential differences in comparison to. An examination of organizational memory in use computer supported cooperative work cscw, vol.
Cotsbased software development processes and open issues 45 the apollo accident 43 42 design guidelines for assessing and controlling spacecraft charging effects spacecraft charging effects nasa electronic parts and packaging nepp 39 1 05022003 standards. The report discusses the definition of cots and cots based system. It describes changes in the software maintenance process that are needed to manage a cots based. Cotsbased processes differ considerably from traditional software development. The failure of these systems is rarely related to a single root. Cots project management strategy from a state government.
In comparison to the software architecture analysis method saam. Common risks and risk mitigation actions for a cots based system most buyers, developers, acquirers, and maintainers of software intensive systems realize that they must use cots products. We propose the ymodel for cots based software product line development. Common risks and risk mitigation actions for a cotsbased system most buyers, developers, acquirers, and maintainers of softwareintensive systems realize that they must use cots products. The cots development process is different from traditional software development and presents many challenges. The work described in this paper is an investigation of cotsbased software development within a particular nasa environment, with an emphasis on the processes used. Cots based software development and integration csiac.
The central part is dedicated to survey methods and techniques that can be useful in cots based development. This whitepaper explains this open, cots based approach and why, a dozen years later, this model finds increasing adoption but has not yet been universally adopted despite its manifold advantages. Free and proprietary software in cotsbased software development. Both processes are different for a project to select an offtheshelf solution rather than having software specially written. A case for architectural assessment for a large financial company. Cots system development process and erp selection 2. A management guide to software maintenance in cotsbased systems.
Cmm of the software engineering institute, the process maturity. Mellon university for the operation of the software engineering institute, a federally funded research and. The main differences occur in the requirement definition, cots selection, highlevel design, integration, and testing phases. The challenges, our approaches, and some open issues. It begins with an outline of the authors methodology for this research, then describes and bounds the problem being addressed. Free software, also known as open source, is a new player in the software world. Free and proprietary software in cotsbased software. Prioritized selecting cots vendor in cotsbased software. Cots based software development within a particular nasa environment, with an emphasis on the processes used. It describes changes in the software maintenance process that are needed to manage a cots based system.
The first new rule of engagement for cots based systems is that the development of a cus tom system is essentially an act of creation, whereas the development of a cots based sys tem is ultimately an act of composition and reconciliation. Sledge software engineering institute although commercial offtheshelf cots products are becoming increasingly popular, little information is available on how they affect existing software development processes or what new processes are needed. Construction and deployment scripts for cots based, open source systems cmusei99tr0 esctr990 wilfred j. For a cots solution strategy, there needs to be a diligent assessment process. Over the past decade, weve witnessed a consolidation of data, control, and presentation integra. When we talk about integration or specifically cots integration, we actually mean the amalgamation of one cots software with other software. Institute sei, we are studying this diversity in the software development process. Cbsd emphasizes the design and development of software systems using preexisting components.
A cots, network softwarebased architecture for effective. Software component reusability is an indispensable part of component based software development life cycle. Then it lists and discusses pros, cons and issues in cots based development. Open source software typically requires extensive integration during implementation. I am often involved in tenders for new pieces of software development work. Taking a cotsbased approach to implementing enterprise gis. Commercialofftheshelf cots based software development has been considered as an alternative strategy to inhouse development. The marketplace is characterized by a vast array of products and product. This process is evaluated to identify essential differences in comparison to traditional software development. Software component selection based on quality criteria using. With the proliferation of objectoriented notations an. This article addresses the software security issue in general and then in the context of developing cotsbased systems.
Documentation related to user requirements from the concept development phase and the planning phase shall be used as the basis for further user needs analysis and the development of detailed requirements. These projects represent a variety of software domains and use more than 30 different cots products. Developing new processes for cotsbased systems lisa brownsword, tricia oberndorf, and carol a. An activity framework for cotsbased systems tricia oberndorf lisa brownsword carol a. Organizational memory as objects, processes, and trajectories. Actualizing organizational memory with information systems. This paper presents an effective decision making framework for software selection in manufacturing industries using a multiple criteria decision making method, preference ranking organization method for enrichment evaluations promethee. The eternal dilemma facing tech leaders is whether to build a business solution from scratch or mold an offtheshelf application to needs of the enterprise. Analyze software requirements software requirements analysis is a critical part of the software development process, although too often this activity is overlooked or glossed over in the rush to start building. Cotsbased software development within a particular nasa environment, with an emphasis on the processes used. As part of that work, we have started to articulate some of the activities and practices that are necessary.
Cots based software development processes and open issues 45 the apollo accident 43 42 design guidelines for assessing and controlling spacecraft charging effects spacecraft charging effects nasa electronic parts and packaging nepp 39 1 05022003 standards. We propose the ymodel for cotsbased software product line development. This paper examines the cots project management strategy and techniques for mentoring of. Software engineering metrics for cots based systems. Software engineering metrics for cots based systems computer. This whitepaper explains this open, cotsbased approach and why, a dozen years later, this model finds increasing adoption but has not yet been universally adopted despite its manifold advantages. Component based software development cbsd endeavors to deliver costeffective and quality software systems through the selection and integration of commercially available software components. Pdf requirements negotiation for cotsbased systems. Aocs information services division isd is currently transforming from being an internal software development shop to being a system integrator through the use of a portfolio of commercial offtheshelf cots based software and will require the data in those cots software to be integrated with the existing jis data. A management guide to software maintenance in cots.
There are three major sources of risks that need to be addressed when it comes to cots based systems. Developing new processes for cots based systems lisa brownsword, tricia oberndorf, and carol a. Common risks and risk mitigation actions over the life cycle. Having components that can be trusted and used in several projects will have a considerable impact on the speed of software development. The model put forward identifies and elaborates the essential phases and activities of software product line development from cots based repository. Strategy defines direction, requires knowledge of desired outcomes, and influences decisions on the allocation of time, people, and money. The requirements analysis phase begins when the previous phase objectives have been achieved.
A management guide to software maintenance in cotsbased. Pdf the objectives of software project management are usually to minimize the project. The development team begins implementation with the following tasks. This strategy was experimented at nasa by considering 15 discrete projects 8.
In each chapter, the special strategies, processes, and considerations for cots development related to that stage of ipds will be identified and discussed. Having a large software system that required an appropriate architecture design that can fulfill the requirements of such software is hard enough to accomplish, and becomes problematic in many cases. A decision tree conceptualization of choice of knowledge transfer mechanism. I n the future, cots products will play an increasingly important role in not only software product engineering but also software engineering tool development. The work described in this paper is an investigation of the cots based software development within a particular nasa environment, with an emphasis on the processes used. The rationale is not just a mandate, as in the case of the dod, but a necessity in todays economy. The other software can either be a cots or noncots. Dec 23, 2000 the goal of this report is to survey the state of the practice in cots based development. Investigating and improving a cotsbased software development.
We think that the following observations can be generalized and could be useful to improve cotsbased software development in any context. More and more software applications, tools and libraries are available as free software, for free as well as proprietary platforms. At this stage requirements are generally less than completely defined and often provide only the most general guidance to the. The objective of this guidebook is to provide planning information that results in costeffective strategies for maintaining commercial offtheshelf cots software products in cots based systems. It considers the issues and risks in using cots software over the life cycle and how to control them. Too much control and flexibility practicum ivan ruchkin institute for software research carnegie mellon university may 9, 2012 abstract as domainspeci c software becomes more available, businesses face a dilemma. Abstract in many software projects, choosing the right architecture is very important factor to deliver reliable software. Software component selection based on quality criteria. I frequently come across tender documents full of questions that scream we are expecting to use a cots product for this system even though ostensibly the process allows sometimes explicitly for the possibility of a bespoke system. Then it lists and discusses pros, cons and issues in cotsbased. It describes changes in the software maintenance process that are needed to. Fifteen projects using a cots based approach were studied and their actual process was documented. Pdf an empirical study of variations in cotsbased software.
This means an open source esb often provides limited options for integrating into systems managing business processes, file transfer and apis. The work described in this paper is an investigation of cots based software development within a particular nasa environment, with an emphasis on the processes used. After this phase, the system enters the operations and maintenance phase for the remainder of the systems operational life. Third international conference, iccbss 2004, redondo beach, ca, usa, february 14, 2004. The main differences, and the activities for which.
Software engineering metrics for cotsbased systems t he paradigm shift to commercial offtheshelfcomponents appears inevitable, necessitating drastic changes to current software development and business practices. Hansen january 2000 cots based systems initiative unlimited distribution subject to the. At this stage requirements are generally less than completely defined and often provide only the most general guidance to the evaluator. Citeseerx document details isaac councill, lee giles, pradeep teregowda. The series of international conferences on cotsbased software systems iccbss has been established as a continuing forum for bringing together cbss developers, s pliers, and researchers to summarize and discuss progress toward understanding and resolving cbss problems.
Execution of standards, methods, and tools for deploying the system carrying out of implementation phase activities according to the detailed project wbs started during the concept development phase. Finally a process to support cotsbased development is proposed, and emerging standards and techniques for component integration are discussed. Introduction in modern cotsbased systems development we need to evaluate the candidate cots components at an extremely early stage in the development process. A methodology for erp misfit analysis sciencedirect. Designing realtime and distributed applications with the. The cots integrated systems are also known as cotsbasedsystems, abbreviated as cbs. Commercial offtheshelf, cots, software, evaluation 1 introduction in modern cots based systems development we need to evaluate the candidate cots components at an extremely early stage in the development process. The model put forward identifies and elaborates the essential phases and activities of software product line development from cotsbased repository.
Cots project management strategy from a state government pmo. An activity framework for cotsbased systems sei digital library. Commercial offtheshelf, cots, software, evaluation 1 introduction in modern cotsbased systems development we need to evaluate the candidate cots components at an extremely early stage in the development process. The objective of this guidebook is to provide planning information that results in costeffective strategies for maintaining commercial offtheshelf cots software products in cotsbased systems. Relationship of wbs to cots functional requirements matrix. Software selection in manufacturing industries using a.
Quality and risk concerns currently limit the application of cotsbased system design to noncritical applications. Introduction in modern cots based systems development we need to evaluate the candidate cots components at an extremely early stage in the development process. Construction and deployment scripts for cotsbased, open. Construction and deployment scripts for cotsbased, open source systems cmusei99tr0 esctr990 wilfred j. Hansen january 2000 cotsbased systems initiative unlimited distribution subject to. The other software can either be a cots or non cots. Supporting actions include training endusers and preparing to turn the system over to maintenance personnel. Common risks and risk mitigation actions over the life. A cots software product is a vital component in cbs.
With implementing the architecture that utilizes commercial off. When documenting the requirements, the requirements engineer should apply the ten useful guidelines to ensure the requirements can, in due course, be used to score candidates in a straightforward manner. Next, the issues surrounding software security are. It is possible for a vendor to issue multiple copies of a product in which the part. The cots integrated systems are also known as cots based systems, abbreviated as cbs. Ppt may 7, 2003 powerpoint presentation free to download. Also, it is important to consider the depth of adapter offerings provided by the esb vendor, especially for packaged. A case for architectural assessment for a large financial. Fifteen projects using a cotsbased approach were studied and their actual process was documented. The method is improved in the present work by integrating with analytic hierarchy process ahp and the fuzzy logic.
Todays need for rapid software development has generated a great interest in employing commercial offtheshelf cots software products as a way of managing cost, developing time, and effort. Mar 14, 2016 when we talk about integration or specifically cots integration, we actually mean the amalgamation of one cots software with other software. It requirements when buying, not making requirements. Specifics about the quantification and application of these factors can be found in 6. Designmethodologyapproach a disciplined process for software product line development is still needed. Cotsbased development is proposed, and emerging standards and techniques. Implementing a cots system design using raytheon ipds and. Risks of commercial offtheshelf cots software bryan. A process to cotsbased software development is devised based on various sdlc processes varying with projects. Objectoriented concepts are crucial in software design because they address fundamental issues of adaptation and evolution.
A cots, network softwarebased architecture for effective and. This process is evaluated to identify essential differences in comparison to traditional. The central problem is how to select a desirable cots software. The central part is dedicated to survey methods and techniques that can be useful in cotsbased development. Free software, also known as opensource, is a new player in the software world. The work described in this paper is an investigation of the cotsbased software development within a particular nasa environment, with an emphasis on the processes used.
1500 174 41 504 1448 338 1378 993 849 72 816 665 113 605 1610 911 1611 1517 670 1437 1095 1228 1205 574 1203 399 1007 94 1531 696 752 804 611 810 554 664 1265 997 1053 974 642